Retirement Life
5 June 2024

The ups and downs of retirement spending

In 1992, my then seventy-six year old mother came back from a three-week trip to Italy. “That”, she said, “is my last big trip”.

 

When wants change

Mum had been an avid traveller, but I knew she really meant that this was the end of her overseas adventures. The post cards and letters I’d received were full of the travails of travel – plumbing that didn’t work, taxis overcharging, dodgy food. She believed she’d had a hard time of it.

 

However, it wasn’t like she’d had a particularly bad run of service in Rome or Florence, nor on the way through in Singapore. I’d received plenty of missives complaining about this and that while she was on previous trips – but this one seemed different.

 

And it was different – now she was 76. Everything was starting to irritate and tire her much more than before, and she found all the mundane little requirements of travel harder. Mum was in good shape – she lived to 97 – but she just couldn’t quite hack it anymore and, most important, it was no longer fun. Things had changed: she was getting older and she just wanted to be home where everything was familiar. She never left New Zealand again.

 

The impact this has on finances

My mother lived out her retirement happily and from this point her expenditure gradually fell. This reduction in spending during retirement has been well recognised and studied and is really quite understandable: as you get older activities like travel become more difficult and less enjoyable, so you do them less. And therefore your costs generally fall.

 

Although it may seem unsettling for a new retiree to spend more in the early years of retirement, it’s what you should do – you can be pretty sure that this higher expenditure early on will be made up for later when spending drops away.

 

Unexpected costs

Of course, life can throw a few curveballs from time to time in the form of unexpected costs with the potential to blow retirement plans out of the water!

 

Take control of your retirement income

On this, Sudipto Banerjee, a retirement thought leader at T Rowe Price (a major US investment firm), has scoured data from various sources and come up with some interesting findings.

 

The important one for me is the number of retirees for whom expenses rose significantly: 50% of retirees experienced up to a 25% increase in their expenditure. Worse, 28% of retirees experienced a 25%-50% hike in expenses, while 21% had a spending increase of 50%-100%.

 

This suggests a substantial number of retirees are receiving some kind of serious shock to their finances.

 

My mother’s expenditure fell as she settled into a more sedentary life. And Banerjee’s findings show that there is indeed an on-average fall in expenditure (about 2% a year) in retirement. However, that decline is not steady; many retirees experience meaningful variations in spending, including some sudden increases.

 

Importantly, these rising expenses were mostly for non-discretionary spending – essential items, in other words, mainly relating to housing, health or transport.

 

Housing

Of the three, housing was the greatest expense, even when people rented. Renters could be hit with sudden rent rises, while owners could uncover major maintenance needs.

 

Many Kiwi homeowners could face further sharp increases in rates and insurance in the coming years, and for some, such increases might not be one-offs. It’s likely that many retirees will have to adapt to ongoing rates increases.

 

Sudden large additional costs are also a big concern for retirees. It might be a one off, but when thinking about retirement it’s important to consider how you’d manage an unexpected house maintenance bill of (say) $25,000, or more.

 

How to plan for the unexpected

Banerjee suggests that all retirees should keep some cash separate from their investment portfolios to cope with such events. Having ready access to cash could be a godsend if something major occurred.

 

Banerjee suggests that retirees should keep one to two years equivalent expenditure in bank deposits, which are quick and easy to get at. I concur completely: when I worked as a financial adviser I always suggested the same.

 

This means that if a couple has a total budget of $50,000 a year, with $30,000 coming from NZ Super and $20,000 from their investments and/or work, I would suggest that they held $20,000 - $40,000 in bank deposits.

 

My recommendation was partly as emergency money, but also to tide people over when markets are down. I’m no great fan of lots of bank deposits and don’t think you should rely on them for most of your funds.

 

Take control of your retirement income

However, I do think that maintaining some liquidity in retirement is worth the generally lower returns you get on money in the bank. If you face a significant cost, some ready cash could be more than useful.

 

Photo of Martin Hawes
Written by:

Martin Hawes

Martin Hawes is not a Financial Adviser or a Financial Advice Provider, and the views in this article are not intended to be financial advice. The views and opinions are general in nature, and may not be relevant to an individual’s circumstances. Before making any investment, insurance or other financial decisions, you should consult a professional financial adviser. Martin Hawes is a director and shareholder in Lifetime Income.

Invest with Lifetime for a retirement income managed for living.

Enjoy more retirement news with Lifetime